I'm actually a little sad this is just a placeholder outfit. It's got a lot going for it. |
- The Fourth Doctor predicts the internet
So, there's a new Doctor in the TARDIS, and it's a woman. Naturally
enough, the internet has exploded with comments ranging from 'the Doctor has
always been male' to 'BBC PC liberal agenda' to 'I look forward to seeing this
fail the way Ghostbusters 2016 failed'. Particularly popular, with each
commenter presumably imagining themselves to be original, are: 'What next,
James Bond as a woman(1)', and 'I'm not sexist, but...'
Special mention to the individual who expressed the hope that now that
the lead in this family show was a woman, the Doctor would be flashing her bits
in the TARDIS. Keeping it classy, internet.
So anyway, as an outspoken would-be superfan, here's my take on the
casting decision that has propelled Whittaker past Foster as 'most frequently searched
Jodie on Google.'
A female actor paying the Doctor(3), and why not? Seriously, the only
even slightly convincing argument I've seen is that the Doctor was one of a
small number of positive, non-violent role models for boys on television,
although anyone who's been paying attention lately would have a hard time
mistaking the Doctor for a role model as Steven Moffatt set out to remodel him
as a dangerous, amoral, petty lunatic. Besides, if we don't have the Doctor,
there's always the companions, as I'm sure women who have complained about the
lack of a female Doctor have been told for decades.
I have no problem in-universe either. Based on regenerations that we
have seen, it's apparent that Time Lords tend
towards a given gender, but can fluctuate (the Master always went male except
Missy, the Doctor always male until now, whereas the General in 'Hell Bent' is
clearly relieved to be back to her more accustomed female form. I get the
feeling that the Corsair was more fluid than most, but we really have no
evidence. No, there is no in-universe issue with the Doctor being a woman.
"Everyone hates her. Not because she's a woman, but because she sucks." |
The main worry I have now is the same one I had about Wonder Woman. Jodie Whittaker is now the
test case for a female Doctor, and by extension for anything outside the white
male mould. After several seasons of hit and miss stories and twelve years of
the still problematic 45-minute single-episode story model you didn't see
anyone protesting the casting of Peter Capaldi on the grounds that 'no white
man could ever be the Doctor', but if they fuck up Whittaker's freshman year
that's the takeaway re casting anyone else. This coming season needs to be gold, and that's a tough demand when you
consider that this must surely be the aim every year. On the upside, we have a
new incoming showrunner, and traditionally the first year of a nuWho
showrunner's residency has been a humdinger. RTD gave us the Ninth Doctor, and
Moffatt the excellent freshman of Eleven. It wasn't until later in their runs
that the good began to be overtaken by the self-indulgent claptrap(4),
messianic bullshit or incomprehensible deconstructive assassination of the main
character. If Chibnall can come in with an equally strong opening, with good
writing by good writers, then we could be looking at something to convince all
but the most diehard naysayers(5).
And what about the Doctor herself? Well, that's going to be fiddly. The
fact that the 13th Doctor is a woman can neither be the be all and
end all of her characterisation, nor a purely cosmetic thing, although for my
money it should tend towards the latter. At all costs, they should avoid the
route taken by Exile of making the
female Doctor a joke(6). She needs to tap into a previously underexplored node
of the Doctor's core personality, but whatever her script is, it should on some
level work for almost any Doctor, give or take a few mannerisms and
catchphrases. She needs, above all, to be the Doctor, as difficult a thing as
that is to get hold of in these days of Time Lords Triumphant and self-loathing
hissy-fits. They should probably steer clear of making her the empathic Doctor
or the nurturing Doctor, and conversely avoid anything too cold and prim.
"It's someone else's gun. Loophole!" |
If I were going to write this(7), I would go for something in a compassionately pragmatic Doctor, willing to go the extra mile for a stranger, but able to make
a hard choice when needed(8). I'm inclined towards the Bakers for a characterisation
guide, big and bold, yet capable of quiet intensity and introspection, but that might just be the coat in the trailer. Oh, but
definitely not RP. It's well established that lots of planets have a north, so
let's stick with that. She should be physically able, but non-violent. There's
precedent for a violent Doctor from Pertwee and both Bakers, and even Davidson
a little, but nuWho has – I think wisely – steered towards a characterisation
that avoids physical conflict most of the time. The 13th Doctor
should stick to that. I'd like to see problem solving and improvisation; quick
wits and incisive intelligence, and the kind of understanding of people that
you should have after millennia moving among them and involving yourself in
their lives. And less sonic, but definitely still a screwdriver(9).
And most of all, I want them not to fuck it up. I want for this
incarnation of the Doctor to be as beloved as any other; more so than some, I
dare say.
(1) Or as we like to call it, Atomic Blonde. Now, I have an idea: James Bond as a decent excuse for a human being(2).
Now there's radical.
(2) Male or female; there are women called James.
(3) I prefer this to 'a female Doctor', as the latter suggests a
gimmick.
(4) There is a definite case to be made in probably all art for not
allowing the creative mind to get comfortable. I'm sure I'd write more if I
didn't have the day job. On the other hand, I have a daughter to support, so the
day job isn't going anywhere.
(5) And let's be honest, you're never going to convince someone whose
stated position is 'I have never watched Doctor Who, but this is a betrayal of
all the series means and another sign of the liberal PC rot in British
society.'
Now there's an idea for the next round of Start to Finish... |
(6) Exile was the sixth Doctor Who Unbound audio play, and saw
the Doctor switch gender after committing suicide to force a regeneration and
avoid the Time Lords at the end of 'The War Games'. As a woman, the Doctor hid
out on Earth, numbing her mind with alcohol and working at a Tesco. That she
was a woman wasn't the core of the joke, but we still ended up with a female
Doctor who was a joke. She finally got to become the Doctor she should have
been all along at the end of the play, moments before it was heavily implied
she was tricked by the Time Lords into triggering her own destruction by
seeking to evade imprisonment within her own TARDIS, which was one hell of a tonal
whiplash.
(7) Chris? Chibbers? Email, yeah?
(8) And, vitally, to make a hard call even when it impacts on her
companions. Being able to sacrifice strangers is callous; being able to
sacrifice yourself is noble; being able to sacrifice a friend to save
strangers, and to live with it, is heroic. Not that I'm saying they ought to
throw a companion under the bus, but to show the Doctor willing would not only
emphasise a different aspect of the character than nuWho's more typical
irrational, overriding love of the companion, it would also create an
interesting new Doctor-companion dynamic if they knew what had almost happened.
(9) Okay, I could live with a variation on the 11th Doctor's
used-once sonic cane made from the handle of Missy's umbrella, but if they
switch the sonic to a 'girly' accessory then I'll rage quit. Sarah Jane's sonic lippy was her thing, and was something that no-one would think to confiscate
because she was a sneaky, undercover journalist. The sonic screwdriver is a
tool, not a spy gadget.
No comments:
Post a Comment